Opinion: Gun control in a free society

Posted

To this retired infantry soldier the commercial sale of military small arms to the general population borders more on insanity than just gross negligence. Military weapons are designed to be competitive killing tools to give our soldiers the edge to survive and win in combat. They are not sporting, hunting rifles or traditional pistols for self-protection and their commercial availability have long exceeded the parameters of prevailing dialogue of “gun control.”

The logic for gun control should be rooted in understanding that the military is dedicated to the defense of the nation while the private sector is dedicated to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. As a consequence, the quintessential difference between the military and the private sector cultures is that the military population is trained and managed collectively as a mission-oriented entity.

Unlike in the private sector, the very intent to kill the enemy is under control and emanate from the national command authority. No member of the military is in position to decide on an ad hoc basis as to when and where the weapon is to be used. The very control of the intended use is a priority task of the entire chain of command during both peace and war.

In stark contrast, the private sector use of weaponry is oriented on sport and self-protection. The private sector examples of both the Las Vegas and Texas Church massacres point to the inability of the private sector to establish control over military small arms now being sold openly as a Second Amendment right assuming that the prospective buyer is a responsible citizen that would act accordingly.

We must acknowledge that times have changed. The key to gun control is to create adequate administrative parameters. Certainly private automobiles today require more management than horse drawn buggies did. Congress must find the wisdom to legislate us out of this gun lobby-driven nightmare because the die is now cast in favor of bigger and even more newsworthy Las Vegas and Texas Church like tragedies. The commercial sale of modern military small arms direly needs serious “special” re-think and intelligent dialogue to reset the tragic runaway cultural trend.

– George Geczy Jr. is a retired U.S. Army colonel and Taos resident.

Comments

3 comments on this story | Please log in to comment by clicking here
Please log in or register to add your comment
Ann Blake

Col. Gecsy nails it. Intelligent open dialogue is needed and needed now.. Mickey Blake, once upon a time Army Lieutenant and Taos National Guard Unit Commander.

Monday, November 13 | Report this
Vince James

"adequate administrative parameters." does not jibe with 'no infringement'. The 2nd amendment implies that the people are as well armed as the military. And that's the point. A government big enough to 'regulated' is also big enough to eradicate.

Tuesday, November 14 | Report this
Robert Andreoli

I take exception to several statements in this piece starting with the title line.

"Gun control in a free society" - In a free society there is no gun control as evidenced buy the 2nd amendment which specifically states "the right of the people to keep and bear arms, shall not be infringed ".

" the commercial sale of military small arms to the general population borders more on insanity than just gross negligence" - I guess that's why the commercial sale of military small arms to the general population was halted with the National Firearms Act of 1934. Those firearms that are available to the general populace are not military grade weapons and are not assault weapons. Even though they may look alike, they are functionally no different than any other conventionally stocked self loading firearm.

"The key to gun control is to create adequate administrative parameters" - Translation = expand a federal bureaucracy that is already out of control and create a state bureaucracy that will cost the tax payers millions we don't have and accomplish nothing. Criminals do not obey the laws that is why we call them criminals. The idea that criminals will stop being criminals because you write a few more laws is what borders on insanity.

"The commercial sale of modern military small arms direly needs serious “special” re-think and intelligent dialogue to reset the tragic runaway cultural trend" - Again, there is no commercial sale of military firearms to the general public nor is there any tragic runaway cultural trend except in the minds of the anti gun crowd. What needs serious “special” re-think and intelligent dialogue is the control of the criminal element in our society as well as the serious mental illness problems that are not being addressed in any meaningful way.

Robert Andreoli (USN Ret.) Arroyo Seco

Friday, November 17 | Report this